MEMDES NZS3404 – Co…
 
Notifications
Clear all

MEMDES NZS3404 – Combined Actions – Yielding Vs Redistributed M*

1 Posts
1 Users
0 Reactions
2 Views
(@1023329)
Active Member
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 2
Topic starter   [#106]
Hello,
 
I would like to check / confirm / clarify my understanding of NZS 3404 and MEMDES operation in this specific example / situation.
 
    (I would provide the relevant MEMDES files and calculation pdf outputs except there does not appear to be an option for attaching files on this forum).
 
    Example – 01
 
For example, checking for a critical load combination case for a 250UB37 column at the superstructure base of a building for a nominally ductile design in MEMDES:
 
The column requires redistribution within 20% limits to a foundation RC plinth type column at the base of the column (continuous via an adequate connection to the foundation plinth).
 
    – Since N* =<   [0.10 x (phi Ns)] ;    alternative provision 4.5.4.2.1, NZS3404 applies.
 
M*x design action input into the MEMDES calculation is post moment redistribution.
 
Length = 2890mm (same for compression buckling lengths about both axis).
Minimum Section Category = 3
M*x = 134 kNm, alpha m = 2.500 ( Ma = 134, Mb = -104, interpolate M* between).
M*y = 5 kNm, 
V*x = 100 kN
End Restraints = FF
kt = kl = kr = 1.0
N* = 100 kN (compression)
 
If choosing the option “Seismic Dsgn – Yielding” in the “Inelastic Design Type” set of options, the requirements of 12.4, 12.5 and 12.6 appear to be checked by MEMDES operation as per requirements in Note to Table 4.5.4.2, NZS3404 and satisfied.
 
MEMDES then checks that Clause 8.1.1.2 part a) is complied with, it is, and on that basis the requirements of section 8.3 only need to be satisfied (i.e. section checks for combined actions only, not member checks as per section 8.4).
 
MEMDES output yields a D/C ratio = 0.999. 
 
    Conclusion:   
 
On the basis noted above I understand that selecting the “Seismic Dsgn – Yielding” option is appropriate in this situation.
 
    Question – 01 :
 
Is there someone more competent in NZS3404 and MEMDES than me that can either confirm or enlighten me on the above conclusion / understanding?
 
    Example – 02 
 
However if the “Moment Redistn Reqd” option in the “Inelastic Design Type” options is selected all other parameters staying the same, MEMDES appears to bypass checking Clause 8.1.1.2 part a) and proceeds to check requirements of section 8.4 instead.
 
This results in MEMDES output yielding a D/C ratio = 1.138   (i.e. 14% over capacity).
 
In this calculation since the Beta-M factors under the “Fire / Advanced” Tab for advanced combined actions were left at the default  (-2.00) values, general member capacity Clauses of section 8.4 are applied and hence the different D/C ratio result to Example-01 (refer Example-03 below).
 
    Question  – 02 :
 
Does anyone know why when selecting the “Moment Redistn Reqd” option in the “Inelastic Design Type”, MEMDES appears to bypass checking Clause 8.1.1.2 part a)? 
 
    (Maybe there is a very good reason).
 
 
    Example – 03
 
Just for completeness.
 
For the Example-02 above, for the MEMDES calculation, when the Beta-M factors for combined actions are actually input then alternative provisions of section 8.4 are used for member capacities about the principle directions and
 
MEMDES output yields a D/C ratio = 1.022    (i.e. within 5%  / essentially same as Example 01).
 
Similar to Example 02, MEMDES appears to bypass checking Clause 8.1.1.2 part a)
 
(with regards to Beta-M factors for this example, M* about principle axis is in double curvature (seismic) and M* about minor axis is triangular with 0 at base, hence Beta-M factors are 1.0 and 0 respectively).
 
 
    Question – 03:
 
What is the key purpose / intended difference in MEMDES for selecting between “Seismic Dsgn – Yielding”  and  “Moment Redistn Reqd” options in the “Inelastic Design Type” selection?
 
(MEMDES Build Version 4.2.1.1768).
 
 
Thanks in advance for your feedback / thoughts.
 


   
Quote
Share: